Mortgage Leads: What to Say on the First Call (Word for Word) | Loan Officer Leadership
Podcast›Episode 519
Episode 519Loan Officer Leadership Podcast · 3 min read

Mortgage Leads: What to Say on the First Call (Word for Word)

Most loan officers lose the deal on the first call by saying too much. Here is the six-step call I make with every new lead, word for word, so the buyer leaves with one clear next step instead of 22 options.

Here is how most first calls go. The buyer asks what rates are doing. And we're off: 22 loan options, where the market is headed, mortgage-backed securities, candlestick patterns. I used to do this all the time.

We're just giving too much information. Clarity doesn't come from information. It comes from one clear next step.

Most homebuyers are cautious by nature. They don't want 22 options. They want to buy a home, and the financing is the obstacle standing between them and the keys. So I built a six-step call that walks them to the next step and nothing else. The whole thing runs three to five minutes.

2 in 3homebuyers apply with only one lender. The first call is where you become that lender.Source: FHFA and CFPB, National Survey of Mortgage Originations, 2024

The Six-Step First Call

  1. 1
    Ask who referred them, then how they met.Everyone is referred by someone, even if it's Google. When it's an agent, ask "How did you meet Tom?" instead of "How do you know Tom?" The answer tells you how deep that relationship is.
  2. 2
    Give a quick loyalty uplift.Validate their choice. "You found one of the best agents in this market. If I were buying today, Tom is exactly who I would use." People feel better about a decision once it's validated.
  3. 3
    Say the words "simple process."Don't jump into rates, payments or cash to close. They're not ready, and you don't have enough information yet. Nobody wants complicated.
  4. 4
    Text the quick questionnaire.It's the application, but "application" sounds hard. Tell them it takes about 10 minutes and gives you what you need to build their clear move plan.
  5. 5
    Book the 30-minute loan consultation."If I move some things around to make you a priority, how about tomorrow at 2?" That's where you cover sales price, monthly payment and cash to close goals.
  6. 6
    Ask them to tell the agent you're taking great care of them.Agents want two things protected: their commission and their reputation. This one sentence helps protect both.

The Whole Call, Word for Word

The First Call

"So glad to talk to you. Who referred you to me? Tom! How did you meet Tom?"

"Well, you ran into one of the best agents I know. If I were buying, I would absolutely use Tom. You're in great hands."

"We've got a very simple process. I'm texting you the quick questionnaire right now. It'll take about 10 minutes, and it gives us what we need to build your clear move plan."

"In your 30-minute loan consultation, we'll go through your sales price range, your monthly payment goals and your cash to close goals, and I'll answer any and all questions. If I move some things around tomorrow, how about 2 o'clock?"

"Is there anything that would prevent you from completing the questionnaire tonight? And would you do me one favor? Let Tom know we're taking great care of you."

Then confirm they got the link, confirm the appointment, and close with this: "We're looking forward to earning your trust and confidence."

Get the First Call Framework.

The full six-step call as a one-page guide you can keep next to your phone. Instant access.

Get the Framework →

What If They Ask About Rate?

Great. Answer it, then lead them right back to the process. They ask about rates because it's all they know. All they've heard is advertising.

When They Ask About Rate

"That's a great question. Rates are made up of 8 to 10 different factors, including credit score, down payment and debt-to-income ratio. The only way to know the specific options available for you is to go through our process."

"I just texted you the quick questionnaire. Did you get it? Tomorrow in our 30-minute loan consultation, we'll walk through the rate options based on your specific goals."

A small number of people will refuse to do anything until you hand them a rate. Handle those as you would. Rate shoppers always shop, and if they won't follow a process that brings clarity, you were likely to lose them anyway.

The bottom line: Don't give more information. Give one clear next step, every time, and lead every question back to your simple process.

Anything worth doing is worth doing badly. Just get started.

Stop running on hope. Start running a system.

The Loan Officer Leadership 5-Day Challenge.

Each day is a teaching video, a worksheet and a walkthrough. You finish each day with the work done, not just learned. It's on demand, so Day 1 opens the moment you join.

See the 5-Day Challenge ›