How Do I Keep Buyers From Shopping Me When Rates Move Higher? | Loan Officer Leadership
Episode 515 · Loan Officer Leadership Podcast

How Do I Keep Buyers From Shopping Me When Rates Move Higher?

When rates move higher, even committed buyers get nervous, start shopping, or put their plans on hold. Here are the six things I'm doing right now to keep them moving forward without making the conversation all about rate.

When rates move higher, even committed buyers get nervous. I may have pre-approved someone a month ago, and now rates are half a point higher. When I go back to update the numbers, they get sticker shock. In this environment, that's when they call another lender for a second opinion.

You're not driving the market. Inflation, the Fed, the headlines, those are market moves. But your clients are yours to lose. And your process is what gives them the confidence to keep moving forward and not shop you every time the market moves.

So here are the six things I'm doing right now.

  1. 1
    Have a processLead every client the same way from first conversation to closing.
  2. 2
    Open the lines of communicationMore volatility means more communication, not less.
  3. 3
    Know your numbersRate history, inventory, and the whole financial picture.
  4. 4
    Give them a hedgeBuy now, refinance later with a no cost refi.
  5. 5
    Communicate your competitive advantageShow them why working with you is about more than rate.
  6. 6
    Close for commitmentNever assume they're committed. Ask.

1. Have a Process

It's more important today than ever that you lead clients through a process. A great first call. A completed application and uploaded docs. Then a 30 minute loan consultation where we build a clear move plan: sales price, monthly payment, cash to close, and answers to any and all of their questions. Same way every time.

2. Open the Lines of Communication

Inside that loan consultation, somebody's going to ask about rates. Whether you bring it up or not, they're thinking about it. So I ask first.

Ask Before You Tell

"What are you hearing about interest rates right now?"

"Do you know what's making that move in the marketplace?"

Their answer tells me where they are mentally. Some people think rates are in the low sixes. Some have seen headlines about the sevens. It tells me how much education they need, and it lets me be the calming force that leads them to what they actually want: their first home, their next home, their dream home.

3. Know Your Numbers

This is how you take the emotion out of it. Data removes emotion. Facts over feeling. Most buyers are comparing today's rates to an emergency period that's unlikely to happen again. Look at the history.

PeriodAverage 30-Year Rate
1970sAbout 9%
1980sAbout 13%
1990sAbout 7.8%
2000 to 20096.18%
2010 to 20194.03%
2020 to present6.26%
Long term median since 19717.1%

Outside of the financial crash and COVID, rates have lived between 6 and 8 percent. Today's rates aren't the lowest they've been. They're also not terrible.

Then I talk about inventory. With four to five and a half months of inventory in my market right now, buyers can find the right home in the right location, condition, and price. And almost every buyer we have, whether the price is 200 thousand or a million, is getting some form of seller contribution. That preserves their cash, and it often goes further than an eighth or a quarter point on the rate.

18 mo. That's how long one of my clients waited for rates to come down. She got a rate about three quarters of a point lower. But the homes in her area went up about 15 percent while she waited, and her monthly payment ended up higher than if she'd bought 18 months earlier.

Waiting doesn't always save you money. Have a story like that ready. Stories sell.

4. Give Them a Hedge

We buy now. My team and I keep an eye on the market, and when rates move lower, we help you refinance with our no cost refi. I don't predict where the market will be. Could be a year, could be four. I just give them the hedge.

Don't have a no cost refi? You do now. Reduce your margin to cover the costs. Yes, you make less on the refi. But you keep the client, you earn the repeat business, and you give them the confidence to buy today. People get excited when they know they're not stuck.

5. Communicate Your Competitive Advantage

When someone asks what makes me different, I tell them working with me gives them the local competitive advantage. Then I show them what that means.

Shop35+ wholesale lendersThe day we go under contract, we shop the loan to find the best rate and lowest cost.
Stay on PlanGroup text updatesText me any address you want to see. I send back the monthly payment and cash to close so you know it fits your goals.
WinI call the listing agentWhen you write an offer, I call the listing agent to let them know how well qualified you are.

We recently won a multiple offer situation that way. The listing agent texted me afterward: we weren't the highest offer, but they felt the most confident in our ability to close quickly with no chaos. Whatever your advantages are, write down two or three and say them every time.

6. Close for Commitment

You can do steps one through five perfectly, and if you don't ask for commitment, you're in trouble. Before I started asking, I was losing about 4 out of 10. In a rising rate environment, I'd bet it's even more.

The Commitment Ask

"Is there anything that would prevent me from being your lender and helping you go all the way through to closing?"

If they say no, you're my guy, high five and move on. If they have an objection, work to overcome it. If they still won't commit, stop putting the full resource of your office behind them until they do. You were going to lose them anyway. Wouldn't you rather know before you put in all the time and effort?

Get Steve's Talking Points guide. The rate history, inventory, and talking points I'm using with buyers right now. Email [email protected] with "Talking Points" in the subject line and the team will send it to you.

Want the full first call and loan consultation process?

The 5-Day Challenge gives you the structure, the scripts, and access to the archive of classes, including the one on asking for commitment. On demand. Start whenever you are ready.

See the 5-Day Challenge →

You're the leader. You're the loan officer. They came to you for a solution. Lead them confidently through the process.

Anything worth doing is worth doing badly. Just get started.

Start with five days

The Loan Officer Leadership 5-Day Challenge.

Each day is a teaching video, a worksheet and a walkthrough. You finish each day with the work done, not just learned. It's on demand, so Day 1 opens the moment you join.

See the 5-Day Challenge →